Many crustaceans, including lobster, crabs, and barnacles, have a cape-like shell protruding from the top that may serve various roles, like a little cave for storing eggs, or perhaps a protective shield to help keep gills moist.
This shell (carapace), it has been proposed, didn’t evolve from any similar structure in the crustacean ancestor, but appeared de novo (or out of nowhere) through somewhat random co-option of the genes that also specify insect wings.
However, in a fresh study from the Marine Biological Laboratory (MBL), Research Associate Heather Bruce and Director Nipam Patel provide evidence for another view: The carapace, and also other plate-like structures in arthropods (crustaceans, insects, arachnids, and myriapods) all evolved from the lateral leg lobe in a common ancestor.
This evidence buttresses their proposal for a fresh idea of how novel structures evolveone that shows that they aren’t so novel, in the end. The analysis, on the carapace of the crustacean Daphnia, appears online in Current Biology.
“How novel structures arise is really a central question in evolution,” Bruce says. “The prevailing idea, called gene co-option, is that genes which are functioning in a single context, tell make insect wings, result in an unrelated context, where they make, say, a carapace,” says Bruce. “But here we show that the Daphnia carapace didn’t just pop out of nowhere.”
Rather, they propose the ancestral, plate-like leg lobe that evolved into both wing and the carapace was likely within the ancestor of most living arthropods. But as the wing and carapace look so not the same as this ancestral plate, and from other plates in neighboring arthropod lineages, no-one realized they were yet thing.
“We have been starting to recognize that structures that don’t look anything alikewings, carapaces, tergal platesare actually homologous,” Bruce says. “That suggests they will have an individual origin that’s a lot more ancient than anyone could have thought, in the past in the Cambrian period, [500 million] years back.”
It had been there all along (cryptic persistence)
“I believe cryptic persistence is definitely an explanation for a number of ‘novel’ structures,” Bruce says.
The authors drew their conclusions by analyzing gene expression patterns in a number of arthropod species, and through the elimination of other hypotheses of the way the carapace could have evolved.
“The ancient, common origin of most these plate-like structures [in arthropods] suggests the gene networks that pattern these structures have become evolvable and plastic. They’re with the capacity of generating an incredible quantity of diversity,” Bruce says.
More info: Heather S. Bruce et al, The Daphnia carapace along with other novel structures evolved via the cryptic persistence of serial homologs, Current Biology (2022). DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2022.06.073
Citation: What’s new beneath the sun? Researchers offer another take on how ‘novel’ structures evolve (2022, August 1) retrieved 2 August 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-08-sun-alternate-view-evolve.html
This document is at the mercy of copyright. Aside from any fair dealing for the intended purpose of private study or research, no part could be reproduced minus the written permission. This content is provided for information purposes only.